megsterz Engineer

[megsterz]

The Rank I'm APPLYING FOR is: Engineer
My Game Name is: megsterz
My Project is called: Tic Tac Toe
To get to my project: X -25146.15876 Y 32.000 Z 5047.15595 in creative, /warp MegTicTacToez
A brief description of my project: Its a game of Tic Tac Toe in minecraft using redstone. I love playing tic tac toe and minecraft so now I did it in one!
Three mandatory screenshots: http://imgur.com/a/nuGGx

[BioZombieActive]

add some screenshots of it in use.

[Hall742]

Well here we go... Your four topics

Uniqueness
Ambition
Execution
Scale


Uniqueness - Naughts and Crosses/Tic Tac Toe has already been done before, not just by me but I have seen a few more from different people so the uniqueness has to be dropped a few points.
Result - 8
Ambition - There isn't anything I can really change here compared to any other Tic Tac Toe, you built what it is and nothing more could be added so I am giving a 7 here.
Result - 7
Execution - I'm going to be honest here, you didn't really build it well, your selection for each player is a large wall of levers, as you pull each lever what you have done is just projected onto a larger display. Now you might be thinking why didn't you build this well? For the player to see what they have chosen they need to move to the side and this will just become a problem. If you had created it so that the view wasn't obstructed by their selection panel it would have scored higher, but at the moment you might as well just played with a 3 x 3 square and each player placed a lever and flipped it either up or down.
Result - 6
Scale - While it is large by the eye the real redstone behind this is small, it gives the illusion the build is large because of the huge display screen but behind the screen is just a simple line of redstone going up from the ground to the pistons.
Result - 7

8 + 7 + 6 + 6 = 27

This is not enough for Engineer as you need 30 points. However you were not far off. The whole soul and essence behind Engineer is new and unique things that haven't been seen before. When I joined the whole concept of redstone minigames was new, of course the infamous door ping pong was around and that created the spark for many other creations that popped up.
If the Ambition and Uniqueness is not there then you will never get the rank as it relies on these two. You scored quite high on these but they weren't quite enough.